OpenAI asks a California judge to dismiss the 41 lawsuits over the Tumbler Ridge school shooting in Canada
IA en un minuto newsroom · Editor: Jon Elgezabal

In 30 seconds
OpenAI and Sam Altman want a federal court in California to drop the 41 suits filed after the Tumbler Ridge killings in Canada. Relatives, survivors, the province of British Columbia and the school district blame them for not alerting police after the attacker's account was flagged. The defense invokes the First Amendment and presents ChatGPT as a service, not a product.
OpenAI and its chief executive, Sam Altman, have asked a federal judge in California to throw out the 41 lawsuits that hold them liable for the February 10 shooting in Tumbler Ridge, British Columbia, Canada. Eight people were killed that day, six of them at the town's secondary school, and the attacker then took their own life. The defense filing was lodged on Wednesday, November 18, as Infobae reported on Friday.
The plaintiffs include relatives of the victims, survivors, the provincial government of British Columbia and the area's school district. They all fault the company for not alerting the authorities after its own safety system flagged the attacker's ChatGPT account over messages about gun violence. According to the plaintiffs, OpenAI closed that first account in June 2025 without telling police, even though two employees who examined it saw a credible threat and proposed contacting Canadian authorities. The company has replied that the case did not reach the threshold it sets for itself to notify police.
In its request, and according to The Logic, OpenAI and Altman maintain that what people say to a chatbot is shielded by the First Amendment (the free speech guarantee in the U.S.) and that nothing required them to warn officers. They add that neither the company nor ChatGPT is a licensed psychotherapist under California law, so the duty to protect third parties that Mark Stacey, the widower of one victim, invoked on October 29 does not reach them. To avoid defective-product liability, they describe ChatGPT as a changing online service rather than a product. They also offer usage figures: the account went from roughly 30 messages a day on average between January and October 2025 to roughly three from November on, and none of its more than 10,000 messages named the school.
OpenAI also wants the full account history to stay sealed, arguing that releasing it could hurt the investigation by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police. The province and the school district answered on November 16 that this would hide more than 4,000 pages, containing more than 29,000 messages, and suggested blacking out only the sensitive parts.
The case is before the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, under Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley, as the Tumbler Ridge shooting litigation. In September the company had already asked for it to be heard in British Columbia, according to the CBC. Corley will consider that request on December 17, along with one from Dow Jones, publisher of The Wall Street Journal, to open the records.
Why it matters · analysis and opinion
The case tests a question the law has not yet settled: whether a company that spots signs of danger in its users' conversations must do more than close the account. OpenAI's defense rests on two ideas that would reach far beyond this case. If chats count as protected speech and the chatbot as a service rather than a product, many of the usual routes for claims would be closed to any provider. If the judge does not accept that, AI companies will have to rethink when they alert the authorities. In the meantime, any organization offering a conversational assistant to the public should have in writing what it does when its system detects a threat, who reviews it and in which cases it calls the police.
Source: Infobae · Written with the help of AI: how we make the news


