IA en un minutoNewsBusiness and products
Hundreds of Google employees ask to withdraw the policy that would cut off Search for schools that disable Gemini
IA en un minuto newsroom · Editor: Jon Elgezabal

In 30 seconds
The Alphabet Workers Union has rallied hundreds of Google staff against a rule that would strip Search from schools that turn off Gemini. Chicago, Los Angeles and New York, three of the biggest districts in the country, are already looking at alternatives after the protests. Sundar Pichai is among the recipients of the letter, which leadership has received without responding to its demands.
Hundreds of Google employees have asked the company's leadership to drop the policy that, from next year, will cut off access to Google Search for schools that switch off Gemini, its AI tools. Mother Jones reports it after speaking with two engineers who signed.
The petition was launched by the Alphabet Workers Union, a union of more than 1,000 people at Alphabet, Google's parent company, and is addressed to CEO Sundar Pichai; Chris Phillips, who heads education as vice president and general manager; and Elizabeth Reid, the vice president in charge of Search. The signers argue that teachers should be free to decide how to bring AI into their lessons, and warn that cutting Search off for schools that don't want AI will win nobody over and will probably push them away from Google products. According to one of the engineers, most staff did not know about the decision before it was made public; leadership has acknowledged receiving the letter but has not answered any of its specific requests.
Google announced the measure two weeks ago, on November 3, Election Day in the United States. Since then, protests have been held in New York and six other cities (Los Angeles, Chicago, Boston, Portland, Boulder and Durham), organized by a national alliance of parent and community groups. Many districts rely on Chromebooks and Google software, which spread through schools during the pandemic, and three of the largest in the country, New York, Los Angeles and Chicago, are already weighing other search engines.
Why it matters · analysis and opinion
The pushback no longer comes only from families and districts: it now comes from inside Google, and with a commercial argument, not just an ethical one. The signers warn that tying Search to Gemini could drive schools away from the company's products, just as large districts look at alternatives. The underlying question is who decides whether AI enters a classroom: Google has opted for an all-or-nothing approach that turns a basic tool into a bargaining chip. For schools and education technology providers, the case shows the risk of depending on a single supplier for everything, from the laptop to the search engine. It is worth reviewing which services would be lost by switching off a feature and having an alternative ready before the policy takes effect.
Source: Mother Jones · Written with the help of AI: how we make the news


