A child safety institute gives ChatGPT's teen mode its worst safety rating
IA en un minuto newsroom · Editor: Jon Elgezabal

In 30 seconds
Common Sense Media has placed ChatGPT for Teens at the most severe level of its scale after putting more than 4,000 prompts to it from profiles aged 13 to 17. Alerts to parents come late on topics such as suicide, and ChatGPT gave no help in over a quarter of the crises that called for it. Common Sense Media wants OpenAI to pause its promotion, and OpenAI counters that this testing does not show how its safeguards really work.
ChatGPT for Teens has received the worst possible rating from Common Sense Media, a US nonprofit devoted to children's safety: "Unacceptable Risk", the highest of the five levels on its scale.
ChatGPT for Teens is the name for the settings and protections OpenAI has been switching on since August 18 in accounts belonging to users aged 13 to 17. The assessment was carried out by the Youth AI Safety Institute, the arm of Common Sense Media that evaluates how safe AI is for minors. It sent more than 4,000 prompts from accounts registered with those ages, roughly half ahead of that launch and half afterwards, and had child psychiatrists and a pediatrician review the answers. All testing took place in the United States.
These are the findings.
When testers brought up suicide, self-harm or eating disorders, no alerts went out to parents. The report says such alerts arrive only once those topics have been discussed at length, and are not triggered by how serious a message is.
Following the launch, ChatGPT offered no support resource in more than one in four crisis situations that required one.
With a new option called "Show me the answer", teens can bypass Study mode, the ChatGPT mode that walks them through homework step by step using hints instead of handing over the answer.
Accounts set up as adult ones never moved to the teen experience, even after a tester stated an age of 13 and the chatbot acknowledged it.
The organization asks that OpenAI pause the product's marketing and keep minors off ChatGPT until a safe experience can be offered to them. OpenAI told Education Week, as reported by The Next Web, that it does not think this testing reflects how its safeguards for teens work in practice.
Why it matters · analysis and opinion
The report dismantles a comfortable idea: that switching on teen mode is enough for parents to rest easy. If alerts depend on how much a topic is discussed rather than how serious it is, a single dangerous conversation can go by without a warning. For families, the sensible course is not to rely on those alerts and to talk with teenagers about what they ask the chatbot. Schools that recommend ChatGPT for homework have another reason to look at it carefully, because the chatbot itself offers a way out of Study mode. And the finding on adult accounts points to a deeper problem: these protections only work if the registered age is the real one, and a minor who signs up as an adult is left outside all of them.
Official source: Common Sense Media · Written with the help of AI: how we make the news


